Where to eat in Tottenville-Charleston, New York
Tottenville-Charleston has 50+ places to eat on our New York map. The most common choices here are Italian, pizza and coffee and sweets. Set a few filters and FeastPick will pick one for you.
Quick picks
Popular in Tottenville-Charleston
Tap a cuisine to pick from just those spots.
Today's picks in Tottenville-Charleston
A fresh, random set of independent spots, reshuffled daily.
Millie's of Staten Island
Pizza · Tottenville-Charleston
Angelina's
Italian · Tottenville-Charleston
Loon Chuan
Chinese · Tottenville-Charleston
Palermo Pizzeria & Restaurant
Pizza · Tottenville-Charleston
Oishi
Japanese · Tottenville-Charleston
Serena Bistro
American · Tottenville-Charleston
Nucci's South Italian Restaurant
Italian · Tottenville-Charleston
Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn
Italian · Tottenville-Charleston
Uncle Sal's Burgers & Wings
Burgers · Tottenville-Charleston
Flores Brunch
Breakfast & brunch · Tottenville-Charleston
John's Deli
Pizza · Tottenville-Charleston
La Rosa Chicken & Grill
Chicken & wings · Tottenville-Charleston
Nearby neighborhoods
How FeastPick works
Tap Pick for me and we'll choose a random spot in Tottenville-Charleston that matches your filters. Not feeling it? Reroll for another option, or veto it so it never comes back this session. Deciding with friends? Start a group pick and everyone can vote from their own phone, no sign-up needed.
Restaurant listings come from OpenStreetMap, a community-maintained map. Opening hours are listed for about 47% of places in Tottenville-Charleston, so "open now" only applies where hours are known. Always double-check before heading out. Last updated October 12, 2026.