Where to eat Italian food in New York
Can't pick between 700+ Italian spots? Narrow it down by neighborhood and let FeastPick choose.
Choosing from 700+ places across 113 neighborhoods.
Quick picks
Best neighborhoods for Italian food
Where New York's Italian spots are most concentrated.
Today's Italian picks in New York
A fresh, random set of independent spots, reshuffled daily.
La Masseria
Italian · Midtown-Times Square
Saragina's
Italian · Bedford-Stuyvesant
Norma
Italian · Hell's Kitchen
Angelina's Kitchen
Italian · New Springville-Willowbrook-Bulls Head-Travis
Valbella at the Park
Italian · Midtown-Times Square
Piccolo Trattoria
Pizza · Italian · Upper East Side-Lenox Hill-Roosevelt Island
San Pietro Restaurant
Italian · Midtown-Times Square
Giovanni’s Brooklyn Eats
Italian · Windsor Terrace-South Slope
Allora 47
Italian · East Midtown-Turtle Bay
Bellucci's Pizzeria
Italian · Pizza · Astoria
Paul & Jimmy's Ristorante
Italian · Gramercy
Zero Otto Nove
Italian · Belmont
Rather cook Italian food at home?
More food in New York
- African
- American
- BBQ
- Breakfast & brunch
- Burgers
- Caribbean
- Chicken & wings
- Chinese
- Coffee, bakery & sweets
- European
- French
- Greek
- Hot dogs
- Indian & South Asian
- Japanese
- Korean
- Latin American
- Mediterranean
- Mexican
- Middle Eastern
- Pan-Asian
- Pizza
- Salads & healthy
- Sandwiches & delis
- Seafood
- Southeast Asian
- Spanish & tapas
- Steakhouse
- Thai
- Vegetarian & vegan
- Vietnamese
How FeastPick works
Set the filters you care about, tap Pick for me, and we'll choose a random spot that matches. Not feeling it? Reroll for another option, or veto it so it never comes back this session. Deciding with friends? Start a group pick and everyone can vote from their own phone, no sign-up needed.
Restaurant listings come from OpenStreetMap, a community-maintained map. Opening hours are listed for about 54% of New York places, so "open now" only applies where hours are known. Always double-check before heading out. Last updated October 12, 2026.